WSM Hammer 9:33 Thu Sep 28
Joe Hart
|
|
Nothing we didn't already know...
http://www.goal.com/en-gb/news/guardiola-was-right-calamity-joe-harts-top-class-career-is/dj327jqed3sf1i5yph8w7985e
|
|
|
Replies - In Chronological Order ( Show Newest Messages First)
Animal
9:38 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
He's done alright thus far.
Not being good enough for the most expensive team in history is not that much of a criticism
|
On The Ball
9:46 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
It's not even that he's not good enough - he just isn't the sweeper keeper that Guardiola wanted.
|
Sven Roeder
9:49 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Guardiola has a very specific style as said and requires a particular type of keeper.
Hart is never going to be that player.
Or the keeper that can save anything down to his left it seems.
|
AKA ERNIE
9:50 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
done nothing yet to justify his signing
|
Trevor B
9:52 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Hasn't shown anything yet to suggest he is any better than Adrian, and certainly not worth his Man City wages of something like 150k, I think? I thought the big difference would be communication, but it doesn't seem to have helped with the defence so far.
|
under the thumb
9:54 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Different class to Adrian, get real.
|
Trevor B
10:01 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
No, he is not. Perfectly real thanks.
|
deanjcrawford
10:09 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
I think this paragraph sums up the whole situation:
"This makes one wonder if Hart was scouted at all by West Ham. Did a club with an unbecoming thirst for headlines, led by David Sullivan and David Gold, the club’s co-chairmen, choose to sign a player who had excelled in making mistakes over the past year, merely on the basis of reputation?"
Yes. Yes they did.
While they stag off Hart's time in Italy, it's worth pointing out that Hart made some spectacular saves, practically earning Torino points by himself.
|
rochesterjohn
10:12 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Not at fault for any of the many goals conceded, that alone puts him in front of Adrian. He tries not to chuck the ball in.
|
Crassus
10:25 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Better keeper than Adrian but, and it's a big but, as many said at the time, if you have a limited budget the incremental improvement against cost would be greater by investing the same elsewhere
Also, let's not forget, the bloke is on a years loan, so after June we either buy at further investment or end up with finding another asAdrian will be off
All in, not the shrewdest of deals was it?
|
bowboy
11:02 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
I think you are all missing the point. Our owners got Hart on loan and they also got 5mil for Randolph, Quids in.That is all they think about.
|
Hermit Road
11:26 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
I don't think he's better than Adrian. He's English, if he wasn't, we would never have heard of him.
|
LeroysBoots
11:35 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Truth is the owners live in this Fucking bubble when players were cheaper and better
They have not set their internal clocks to next level
They live in the past
Senile CUNTS
|
camel-with-3-humps
11:39 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Adrian is a more spectacular keeper who will save you points - but prone to errors.
Hart is free from errors but not very special at shot stopping. Seems a bit slow to be honest.
|
Mart O
11:42 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Quite clear he's no good down low and poor to his left.
This is not good for a PL goalkeeper.
Good at pointing and shouting, however.
|
WHUDeano
11:48 Thu Sep 28
Re: Joe Hart
|
Was happy with his signing and to be fair he hasn't stood out due to mistakes, he also hasn't stood out due to doing anything special. Just seems a bog standard goal keeper who doesn't do anything rash. Looking back on other keepers we've had while struggling near the bottom, the likes of Ludo, Rob Green, even Dave James all looked of a different level to Hart. Given his history & reputation he's definitely been a disappointment so far.
|
Swiss.
6:24 Fri Sep 29
Re: Joe Hart
|
There's a few goals he's let in I recon Adrian would have saved.
|
Sir Alf
6:27 Fri Sep 29
Re: Joe Hart
|
Average keeper so far. We have seen far more of Adrian but so far I would put him ahead of Hart. Adrian is prone to the odd rickett but is more agile IMO and faster off his line to make blocks.
A loan signing we could have applied to more urgent areas of the team in hindsight.
|
SurfaceAgentX2Zero
6:36 Fri Sep 29
Re: Joe Hart
|
I dislike the self-assured way he always kicks the ball straight to the opposition.
I'd rather he was less confident and more accurate.
|
Tomsdad
6:44 Fri Sep 29
Re: Joe Hart
|
Swiss. 6:24 Fri Sep 29
Not sure how you know Adrian would have saved them, but you could also say he saved a few shots that Adrian would have let in.
Swings and Roundabouts!
|
| 
